Exploring themes of nostalgia, loss, and emotional turmoil, this song delves into the complexities of a past relationship. The recurring journey "back to Sullivan St." symbolizes a return to memories that are both haunting and comforting. The imagery of "crossing the water" and "shadows that fall" suggests an emotional passage through time and unresolved feelings. The protagonist is "almost drowning in her sea," indicating overwhelming emotions tied to the woman he sings about, who is also struggling as she is "nearly crawling on her knees." This mutual suffering highlights their deep connection yet inevitable separation. Ultimately, the narrator's indifference—"Either way now, I don't really care"—suggests resignation and acceptance of the unchangeable past. This poignant reflection captures the bittersweet nature of holding onto memories while recognizing their power over one's present state.
